Политическая полиция конца XIX-начала XX вв. и "революция": игра понятием или реальная угроза?

Второй съезд земских деятелей. -- СПб., 1904. -- 6-9 ноября 1904.

Герасимов А. В. На лезвии с террористами // Охранка. Воспоминания руководителей политического сыска. В 2 т. Т. 2. -- М. : Новое литературное обозрение, 2004.

Мартынов А.П. Моя служба в Отдельном корпусе жандармов // Охранка. Воспоминания руководителей политического сыска. В 2 т. Т. 1. -- М. : Новое литературное обозрение, 2004.

Новицкий В.Д. Из воспоминаний жандарма. -- М. : Издательство МГУ, 1991. О дворянине Михаиле Иванове Туган-Барановском. Л. 157. Справка // ГАРФ. --1899 -- Ф. 102. -- з делопроизводство. -- 1899. -- Д. 1055.

Свод законов Российской империи. Т. 1. Ч. 2. -- СПб., 1906.

Спиридович А. Записки жандарма. -- М. : Художественная литература, 1991. Заварзин П. П. Жандармы и революционеры // Охранка. Воспоминания руководителей политического сыска. В 2 т. Т. 2. -- М. : Новое литературное обозрение, 2004a.

Заварзин П. П. Работа тайной полиции // Охранка. Воспоминания руководителей политического сыска. В 2 т. Т. 1. -- М. : Новое литературное обозрение, 2004b.

Литература

Анисимов Н. Н. Борьба большевиков против политической тайной полиции самодержавия (1903-1917). -- 1989.

Бедекер Э. Размышления о методе истории понятий / пер. с нем. В. Дубиной // История понятий, история дискурса, история метафор. -- М. : Новое литературное обозрение, 2010. -- С. 34-65.

Борьба за массы в трех революциях в России: Пролетариат и средние городские слои / В. П. Булдаков [и др.]. -- М. : Мысль, 1981.

Ведерников В. В., Китаев В. А., Луночкин А. В. Конституционный вопрос в русской либеральной публицистике 60-80-х гг. XIX в. -- М. : Магистр, 1997.

Гинзбург К. Мифы-эмблемы-приметы: морфология и история / пер. с итал. С. Л. Козловой. -- М. : Новое литературное обозрение, 2004.

Додонов Б. Ф, Кирьянов Ю. И. Обзор архивных источников об основных формах массового рабочего движения в России, 1895 - февраль 1917. -- М., 1990.

Карелин А. П. Русский полицейский социализм // Вопросы истории. -- 1968. -- № 10. -- С. 41-58.

Кильдюшов О. В. Полиция как наука и политика: о рождении современного порядка из философии и полицейской практики // Социологическое обозрение. -- 2013. -- Т. 12, № 3. -- С. 9-40.

Козьмин Б. П. С. В. Зубатов и его корреспонденты. Среди охранников, жандармов и провокаторов. -- М., Ленинград : Государственное издательство, 1928.

Кранихельд В. В. Я. Яковлев-Богучарский (по материалам Департамента полиции, Московского охранного отделения и по личным воспоминаниям) // Былое. -- 1917. -- Т. 23, № 1.

Павлов Б.Д. Эсеры-максималисты в Первой русской революции. -- М. : Издательство Всесоюзного заочного политехнического института, 1989.

Перегудова З. И. Политический сыск России. -- М. : Российская политическая энциклопедия, 2000.

Революция и общественное движение в Сибири в конце XIX - начале XX в. -- Новосибирск : Наука, 1986.

Реент Ю. А. Полицейская система Российской империи начала XX в. (1900-1917) : дис. ... д-ра ист. наук : 07.00.02 / Реент Ю. А. -- М. : Московский государственный университет, 2002.

Рууд Ч., Степанов С. Фонтанка, 16. -- М. : Мысль, 1993.

Самосудов В. М. Большевики Сибири в борьбе против царизма (1894 - февраль 1917 г.) -- Иркутск : Издательство Иркутского университета, 1987.

Словарь основных исторических понятий : избранные статьи. В 2 т. Т. 1. Революция (Revolution), бунт, смута, гражданская война (Rebellion, Aufruhr, Bьrgerkrieg) / Н. Бульст [и др.] ; сост. Ю. Зарецкого, К. Левинсона, И. Ширле; пер. с нем. К. Левинсон. -- М. : НЛО, 2014. -- С. 520-728.

Соловьева М. В. Царские провокаторы и дело социал-демократической фракции II Государственной Думы // Вопросы истории. -- 1966. -- № 8.

Ульянова (Бибикова) Л. В. «Обезвредить хирургическими мерами нельзя»: либеральное движение глазами политической полиции (1880-1905 гг.) // Траектория в сегодня: россыпь историко-биографических артефактов. -- Челябинск : Энциклопедия, 2009a. -- С. 232-247. -- К юбилею профессора И. В. Нарского.

Ульянова (Бибикова) Л. В. Политическая полиция и либеральное движение, 1880-1905 гг. : дис. ... канд. ист. наук : 07.00.02 / Ульянова (Бибикова) Л. В. -- М. : Московский государственный университет, 2009b.

Ульянова (Бибикова) Л. В. Социально-профессиональный портрет политической полиции Российской империи (1880-1905) // Вестник Пермского университета. -- 2009c. -- Т. 9, № 2. -- С. 92-101.

Уортман Р. Властители и судии: развитие правового сознания в императорской России / пер. с англ. М. Л. Долбилова, Ф. Л. Севастьянова. -- М. : Новое литературное обозрение, 2004.

Филиппов А. Ф. К исторической ситуации полиции в России // Социологическое обозрение. -- 2013. -- Т. 12, № 2. -- С. 41-42.

Шацилло К. Ф. Русский либерализм накануне революции. -- М. : Наука, 1985.

Эренфельд Б. К. Тяжелый фронт. Из истории борьбы большевиков с царской тайной полицией. -- М. : Политиздат, 1983.

Beer D. “Microbes of the Mind”: Moral Contagion in Late Imperial Russia // The Journal of Modern History. -- 2007. -- No. 79. -- P. 532-537.

Raeff M. The Well-Ordered Police State: Social and Institutional Change through Law in the Germanies and Russia, 1600-1800. -- Yale University Press, 1983.

LYUBOV' BIBIKOVA

PHD IN HISTORY, SENIOR LECTURER AT THE LOMONOSOV MOSCOW STATE UNIVERSITY THE POLITICAL POLICE AT THE TURN OF THE TWENTIETH CENTURY AND THE “REVOLUTION”: A GAME OF CONCEPT OR THE REAL THREAT?

Abstract: This article is concerned with the interpretation of the concept of revolution by various structures of the political police of the Russian Empire of the late 19th - early 20th centuries (Department of police, security departments, provincial gendarmerie management) -- the union of state institutions which had to fight the revolution. In the frames of the history of concepts developed by R. Kozellek, attention is drawn to the fact that the revolution alike the concepts of troubles, revolt, uprising, and civil war is aiming at changing of the state system, on fundamental transformations in the political system of the country. The theoretical framework for the explication of this approach to the records of political investigation is the concept of evidence paradigm proposed by K. Ginzburg to describe the process of the formation of state control over society in the European countries of the period of becoming Modern. According to the officials of the political police of the Russian Empire, revolutionaries were those who aimed to overthrow the existing system; those who belonged to the underground resistance. But they were not those who did the most for the benefit of the revolution on an all-Russian scale--not compared to the socio-political groups that existed in the legal space and had access to the publicity. At the same time, gendarmes regarded everyone, who did not consider himself an ohranitel (Russian for conservator) as a representative of revolutionary legal socio-political forces. The Police Department of Russia regarded not only underground revolutionaries themselves to be a revolutionary threat, but also the radicals, the opposition members, and the radical liberals; liberals in general, though, were not considered to be the agents of the revolution. Two images of revolution, which were formed within the system of the political police, in general correspond with the two concepts of revolution, described by R. Kozellek. In the first, which is chronologically younger, revolution is considered to be an exclusively political phenomenon concerned with the change of the bases of a state system (which actually occurred in 1905). The second image of the revolution, which originated in Europe in the middle of the 19th century, suggested the distinction of political revolution (i. e. one that is concerned with the state-civil, constitutional and legal side) and social revolution (concerned with the society). Analysis of the correspondence of the political investigation forces of the Russian Empire at the turn of the i9th--20th centuries shows that this image of the revolution resonated with the leadership of the political police (i. e. the officials of the Department of police) by the beginning of the 20th century. In this sense, the events of the revolutionary 1905 year had primary importance for them not so much in terms of changes in the state system (as it was for the gendarmes), but as an inevitable reflection of the transformational processes that took place in the Russian society.

Keywords: Russian Political Police, the Concept of Revolution, Police Department of Russia, Gendarmerie, History of Ideas, Radicalism, Ruling Elites of the Russian Empire.

REFERENCES

Anisimov, N.N. 1989. “Bor'ba bol'shevikov protiv politicheskoy taynoy politsii samoderzhaviya (1903-1917) [The Struggle of Bolsheviks with the Political Secret Police of the Autocracy (1903-1917)]” [in Russian]. (Sverdlovsk).

Bedeker, E. [Bцdeker, H.E.] 2010. “Razmyshleniya o metode istorii ponyatiy [Ausprдgungen der hist orischen Semantik in den historischen Kulturwissenschaften]” [in Russian]. In Istoriya ponyatiy, istoriya diskursa, istoriya metafor [Begriffs-geschichte, diskurs-geschichte, metaphern-geschichte], trans. from the German by V. Dubina, 34-65. Moskva [Moscow]: Novoye literaturnoye obozreniye.

Beer, D. 2007. “`Microbes of the Mind': Moral Contagion in Late Imperial Russia.” The Journal of Modern History, no. 79: 532-537.

Buldakov, V.P., et al. 1981. Bor'ba za massy v trekh revolyutsiyakh v Rossii: Proletariat i sredniye gorodskiye sloi [The Fight for the Masses in Three Russian Revolutions: Proletariat and Urban Middle Class] [in Russian]. Moskva [Moscow]: Mysl'.

Dodonov, B.F., and Yu.I. Kir'yanov. 1990. Obzor arkhivnykh istochnikov ob osnovnykh formakh massovogo rabochego dvizheniya v Rossii, i8g§ - fevral' igij [Review of the

Principal Archival Sources on the Main Forms of Mass Labor Movement in Russia, 1895 - February 1917] [in Russian]. Moskva [Moscow].

Erenfel'd, B.K. 1983. Tyazhelyy front. Iz istorii bor'by bol'shevikov s tsarskoy taynoy politsiyey [A Difficult Front. From the History of the Struggle of the Bolsheviks and the Tsarist Secret Police] [in Russian]. Moskva [Moscow]: Politizdat.

Filippov, A.F. 2013. “K istoricheskoy situatsii politsii v Rossii [On the Historical Situation with the Police in Russia]” [in Russian]. Sotsiologicheskoye obozreniye [Russian Sociological Review] 12 (2): 41-42.

Gerasimov, A. V. 2004. “Na lezvii s terroristami [On the Edge with the Terrorists]” [in Russian]. In vol. 2 of Okhranka. Vospominaniya rukovoditeley politicheskogo syska [Okhrana. Memoirs of the Domestic Intelligence Head Officers]. 2 vols. Moskva [Moscow]: Novoye literaturnoye obozreniye.

Ginzburg, K. 2004. Mify-emblemy-primety: morfologiya i istoriya [Miti, emblemi, spie. Morfologia e storia] [in Russian]. Trans. from the Italian by S.L. Kozlova. Moskva [Moscow]: Novoye literaturnoye obozreniye.

Karelin, A.P. 1968. “Russkiy politseyskiy sotsializm [Russian Police Socialism]” [in Russian]. Voprosy istorii [Issues of History], no. 10: 41-58.

Kil'dyushov, O.V. 2013. “Politsiya kak nauka i politika: o rozhdenii sovremennogo poryadka iz filosofii i politseyskoy praktiki [Police as Science and as Politics: On the Birth of the Contemporary Order from the Philosophy and Political Practice]” [in Russian]. Sotsiolo- gicheskoye obozreniye [Russian Sociological Review] 12 (3): 9-40.

Koz'min, B.P. 1928. S. V. Zubatov i yego korrespondenty. Sredi okhrannikov, zhandar- mov i provokatorov [S. V. Zubatov and His Correspondents. Amongst the Guards, Gendarmes and Provocateurs] [in Russian]. Moskva [Moscow] and Leningrad: Gosudar- stvennoye izdatel'stvo.

Kranikhel'd, V. 1917. “V.Ya. Yakovlev-Bogucharskiy (po materialam Departamenta politsii, Moskovskogo okhrannogo otdeleniya i po lichnym vospominaniyam) [V.Ya. Yakovlev-Bo- gucharsky (on the Materials of Police Department, Moscow Secret Police, and Personal Memories)]” [in Russian]. Byloye [The Past] 23 (1).

Martynov, A. P. 2004. “Moya sluzhba v Otdel'nom korpuse zhandarmov [My Service in The Special Gendarme Corps]” [in Russian]. In vol. 1 of Okhranka. Vospominaniya rukovo- diteley politicheskogo syska [Okhrana. Memoirs of the Domestic Intelligence Head Officers]. 2 vols. Moskva [Moscow]: Novoye literaturnoye obozreniye.

Novitskiy, V.D. 1991. Iz vospominaniy zhandarma [From the Memories of a Gendarme] [in Russian]. Moskva [Moscow]: Izdatel'stvo MGU.

“O dvoryanine Ivane Petrove Belokonskom. L. 69-70. Doneseniye nachal'nika Orlovskogo zhan- darmskogo upravleniya [Concerning Ivan Petrov Belokonskiy, a Nobleman. P. 69-70. Report of the Head of the Oryol Gendarmes Department]” [in Russian]. 1893. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/1893/820.

“O dvoryanine Mikhaile Ivanove Tugan-Baranovskom. L. 157. Spravka [About Nobleman Mikhail Ivanov Tugan-Baranovskiy. P. 157. Reference]” [in Russian]. 1899. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1899/1055.

“O knyaze Dmitrii Ivanove Shakhovskom, obvinyayemom v politicheskoy neblagonadezhnosti. Perepiska [Concerning Prince Dmitriy Ivanov Shakhovskiy, Accused of Political Unreliability. Correspondence]” [in Russian]. 1903. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/7/1903/1791.

“O knyaze Dmitrii Ivanove Shakhovskom, obvinyayemom v politicheskoy neblagonadezhnosti. Perepiska [Concerning Prince Dmitry Ivanov Shakhovsky, Accused of Political Unreliability. Correspondence]” [in Russian]. 1903. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/7/1903/1791/93.

“O knyaze Dmitrii Ivanoviche Shakhovskom. Perepiska [Concerning Prince Dmitry Ivanovich Shakhovsky. Correspondence]” [in Russian]. 1891. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1891/527.

“O legal'noy oppozitsii. L. 3 ob--4. Zapiska dlya pamyati [About Legal Opposition. P. 3 ob--4. Note for Memory]” [in Russian]. 1902. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102. Special Department. 1902/835.

“O legal'noy oppozitsii. L. 7. Zapiska dlya pamyati [About Legal Opposition. P. 7. Note for Memory]” [in Russian]. 1902. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102 (Special Department). 1902/835.

“O moskovskom yuridicheskom obshchestve. L. 7, 11, 13-14, 15-16. Perepiska [Concerning Moscow Law Society. P. 7, 11, 13-14, 15-16. Correspondence]” [in Russian]. 1889. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1889/87/503.

“O pomoshchnike prisyazhnogo poverennogo Petre Berngardove Struve. L. 162a. Zapiska [Concerning Petr Berngardovich Struve, an Assistant Attorney in Law. P. 162a. Note]” [in Russian]. 1894. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/91/1894/202.

“O professore Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta Petre Frantseve Lesgafte. L. 58. Tsirkulyar [Concerning Peter Frantsevich Lesgaft, a Professor of St. Petersburg University. P. 58. Circulaire]” [in Russian]. 1893. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1893/91/434.

“O sostoyashchikh pri Imperatorskom Vol'nom Ekonomicheskom obshchestve Sankt-Peter- burgskom i Moskovskom komitetakh Gramotnosti. L. 120, 138-143. Perepiska [Concerning the St. Petersburg and Moscow Literacy Committees Attached to the Free Economic Society for the Encouragement of Agriculture and Husbandry. P. 120, 138-143. Correspondence]” [in Russian]. 1893. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1893/91/635.

“O soveshchaniyakh v dekabre 1901 g. i yanvare 1902 g. pod predsedatel'stvom gospodina direk- tora Departamenta politsii nachal'nikov nekotorykh gubernskikh zhandarmskikh upravle- niy, v rayonakh koikh zamechayet-sya osoboye razvitiye revolyutsionnoy propagandy. L. 64. Doneseniye nachal'nika Vladimirskogo zhandarmskogo upravleniya [Concerning Meetings in the December, 1901 and January, 1902 under the Chairmanship of Mr. Director of Department of Policy Chiefs of Some Provincial Gendarmes' Offices, in Areas where the Rise of Revolutionary Propaganda is Especially Noticed. P. 64. Report of the Head of the Vladimir Gendarmerie Department]” [in Russian]. 1901. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102. Special Department. 1901/987.

“O syne nadvornogo sovetnika Genrikhe Adol'fove Fal'borke. L. 6. Spravka [Concerning Heinrich Adol'fovich Fal'bork, a Court Counselor's Son. P. 6. Reference]” [in Russian]. 1893. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1893/1199.

“O tverskom zemstve. Vsepoddanneyshiy otchet. L. 3-16 [Concerning the Tver Zemstvo. The Most Allegiant Report. P. 3-16. Report]” [in Russian]. 1895. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1895/1719.

“O vdove senatora taynogo sovetnika Aleksandre Mikhaylove Kalmykovoy. L. 6. Spravka [Concerning Aleksandra Mikhaylova Kalmykova, a Widow of the Senator of the Privy Councilor. P. 6. Reference]” [in Russian]. 1893. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1893/1200.

“O zakrytii Moskovskogo Obshchestva vzaimopomoshchi lits intelligentnykh professiy. L. 2, 6. Doneseniye [Concerning Dismission of the Moscow Society Mutual-Aid for the Persons in the Intellectual Professions. P. 2, 6. Report]” [in Russian]. 1901. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1901/933.

Pavlov, B. D. 1989. Esery-maksimalisty v Pervoy russkoy revolyutsii [Social-Revolutionary Maximalists in the First Russian Revolution] [in Russian]. Moskva [Moscow]: Izdatel'- stvo Vsesoyuznogo zaochnogo politekhnicheskogo instituta.

Peregudova, Z.I. 2000. Politicheskiy sysk Rossii [Political Investigation in Russia] [in Russian]. Moskva [Moscow]: Rossiyskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya.

“Po soobshcheniyam nachal'nika Tverskogo gubernskogo zhandarmskogo upravleniya. L. 87-89. Doneseniye [Reported by the Head of the Tver Provincial Gendarmerie Department. P. 87-89. Report]” [in Russian]. 1888. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1888/84/23

“Po soobshcheniyam zaveduyushchego Parizhskoy agenturoy i po perepiske s nim. L. 280-281. Doneseniye [Reported by the Chief of Paris Net of Agents through Correspondence with Him. P. 280-281. Report]” [in Russian]. 1886. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1888/89/32.

“Po soobshcheniyam zaveduyushchego Parizhskoy agenturoy i po perepiske s nim. L. 69-69 ob. Doneseniye [Reported by the Chief of Paris Net of Agents through Correspondence with Him. P. 69-69 ob. Report]” [in Russian]. 1891. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1891/1.

“Politicheskiy obzor po Chernigovskoy gubernii. L. 15. Politicheskiy obzor [Political Review of Chernigov Governorate. P. 15. Political Review]” [in Russian]. 1905. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102. Special Department. 1905/1/106/11.

“Politicheskiy obzor po Tverskoy gubernii. Politicheskiy obzor [Political Review of Tver Gov- ernorate. Political Review]” [in Russian]. 1885. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1885/59/40/32.

“Politicheskiy obzor po Tverskoy gubernii. Politicheskiy obzor [Political Review of Tver Gov- ernorate. Political Review]” [in Russian]. 1885. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1885/59/40/4.

“Politicheskiy obzor po Tverskoy gubernii. Politicheskiy obzor [Political Review of Tver Governorate. Political Review]” [in Russian]. 1888. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1888/89/32/2.

“Politicheskiy obzor po Tverskoy gubernii. Politicheskiy obzor [Political Review of Tver Gov- ernorate. Political Review]” [in Russian]. 1889. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/1889/43/29.

“Politicheskiy obzor po Tverskoy gubernii. Politicheskiy obzor [Political Review of Tver Gov- ernorate. Political Review]” [in Russian]. 1885. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/3/81/1885/59/40/2.

“Proizvedeniya nelegal'noy pechati. Snosheniya chlenov Londonskoy gruppy s kruzhkom sankt-pe- terburgskikh liberalov, namerevayushchikhsya izdavat' v Londone svoy spetsial'nyy organ `Zemskiy sobor'. L. 2 ob. Doneseniye zaveduyushchego Zagranichnoy agenturoy [Works of Illegal Press. between the Members of the London Group and the Group of St. Petersburg Liberals, Intending to Publish in London `Zemsky Sobor', Their Special Organ of the Press. P. 2 ob. Reports of Chief of Paris Net of Agents]” [in Russian]. 1898. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102 (Special Department). 1898/226/14/6.

Raeff, M. 1983. The Well-Ordered Police State: Social and Institutional Change through Law in the Germanies and Russia, 1600-1800. Yale University Press.

Revolyutsiya i obshchestvennoye dvizheniye v Sibiri v kontse XIX - nachale XX v. [Revolution and Social Movement in Siberia in the Late Nineteenth - Early Twentieth Century] [in Russian]. 1986. Novosibirsk: Nauka.

Reyent, Yu.A. 2002. “Politseyskaya sistema Rossiyskoy imperii nachala XX v. (1900-1917) [Police System of the Russian Empire in the Beginning of Twentieth Century]” [in Russian]. Doctoral diss., Moskovskiy gosudarstvennyy universitet.

Ruud, Ch., and S. Stepanov. 1993. Fontanka, 16 [Fontanka, 16] [in Russian]. Moskva [Moscow]: Mysl'.

Samosudov, V. M. 1987. Bol'sheviki Sibiri v bor'be protiv tsarizma (i8g4 - fevral' 191J g.) [The Bolsheviks of Siberia in the Fight against Tsarism (18g4 - February igij)] [in Russian]. Irkut-sk: Izdatel'stvo Irkut-skogo universiteta.

Shatsillo, K.F. 1985. Russkiy liberalizm nakanune revolyutsii [Russian Liberalism on the Eve of Revolution] [in Russian]. Moskva [Moscow]: Nauka.

Solov'yeva, M.V. 1966. “Tsarskiye provokatory i delo sotsial-demokraticheskoy fraktsii II Go- sudarstvennoy Dumy [Tsarist Provocateurs and the Case of Social-Democratic Faction of the 2nd State Duma]” [in Russian]. Voprosy istorii [Issues of History], no. 8.

Spiridovich, A. 1991. Zapiski zhandarma [Gendarme's Notes] [in Russian]. Moskva [Moscow]: Khudozhestvennaya literatura.

“Svod dannykh Departamenta Politsii o proyavleniyakh bor'by protiv pravitel'stva na legal'noy pochve v Sankt-Peterburge. L. 2. Zapiska dlya pamyati [The Set of Data of the Police Department on the Manifestations of the Fight against the Government on Legal Grounds in St. Petersburg. P. 2. Note for Memory]” [in Russian]. 1898. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102. Special Department. 1898/723.

Svod zakonov Rossiyskoy imperii [The Code of Laws of the Russian Empire] [in Russian]. 1906. Vol. 1, bk. 2. Sankt-Peterburg [Saint Petersburg].

Uortman, R. [Wortman, R.] 2004. Vlastiteli i sudii: razvitiye pravovogo soznaniya v im- peratorskoy Rossii [The Development of a Russian Legal Consciousness] [in Russian]. Trans. from the English by M.L. Dolbilov and F.L. Sevast'yanov. Moskva [Moscow]: Novoye literaturnoye obozreniye.

Vedernikov, V.V., V.A. Kitayev, and A.V. Lunochkin. 1997. Konstitutsionnyy vopros v rus- skoy liberal'noy publitsistike 60-80-kh gg. XIX v. [The Issue of Constitution in the Russian Liberal Journalism of the 60-80-th Years of Nineteenth Century] [in Russian]. Moskva [Moscow]: Magistr.

“Vnutrennyaya agentura. Agenturnyye svedeniya iz Moskvy. L. 192-193. Perepiska [Internal Net of Agents. Intelligence Information from Moscow. P. 192-193. Correspondence]” [in Russian]. 1898. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102. Special Department. 1898/2/1/B.

“Vnutrennyaya agentura. Lichnoye i denezhnoye delo sotrudnika M.I. Khar'kovtseva. L. 64. Zapiska [Internal Net of Agents. Personal Records and Expense Report of M.I. Garkavtsev, an Operative. P. 64. Note]” [in Russian]. 1898. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102/316/1898/2/5/1.

Vtoroy s''yezd zemskikh deyateley [The Second Congress of Zemstvo Figures] [in Russian]. 1904. 6-9 noyabrya 1904 [6-9 November 1904], Sankt-Peterburg [Saint Petersburg].

“Zapiski nachal'nikov okhrannykh otdeleniy o revolyutsionnykh organizatsiyakh v ikh rayonakh. L. 48. Zapiska nachal'nika Moskovskogo otdeleniya po okhraneniyu obshchestven- noy bezopasnosti. O postanovleniyakh noyabr'skogo zemskogo s''yezda 1904 g. [Notes by the Heads of Security Departments about the Revolutionary Organizations in Their Areas. P. 48. Notes by the Head of Moscow Department on the Protecting the Public Security and Order]” [in Russian]. 1904. In GARF [State Archive of the Russian Federation]. 102. Special Department. 1904/1195.

Ul'yanova (Bibikova), L.V. 2009a. “`Obezvredit' khirurgicheskimi merami nel'zya': liberal'- noye dvizheniye glazami politicheskoy politsii (1880-1905 gg.) [`Cannot be Neutralised by a Surgical Intervention': Liberal Movement as Viewed by the Political Police (1880-1905)]” [in Russian]. In Trayektoriya v segodnya: rossyp' istoriko-biograficheskikh artefaktov [Trajectory into Today: Scattering of the Historical and Biographical Artifacts], 232247. K yubileyu professora I.V. Narskogo [To the Anniversary of Professor I.V. Narsky]. Chelyabinsk: Entsiklopediya. - 2009b. “Politicheskaya politsiya i liberal'noye dvizheniye, 1880-1905 gg. [Political Police and Liberal Movement. 1880-1905]” [in Russian]. PhD diss., Moskovskiy gosudarstvennyy universitet. - 2009c. “Sotsial'no-professional'nyy portret politicheskoy politsii Rossiyskoy imperii (1880

1905) [Social and Professional Portrait of the Political Police in the Russian Empire (1880-1905)]” [in Russian]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta [Perm University Herald] 9 (2): 92-101.

Zavarzin, P. P. 2004a. “Zhandarmy i revolyutsionery [Gendarmes and Revolutionaries]” [in Russian]. In vol. 2 of Okhranka. Vospominaniya rukovoditeley politicheskogo syska [Okhrana. Memoirs of the Domestic Intelligence Head Officers]. 2 vols. Moskva [Moscow]: Novoye literaturnoye obozreniye. - 2004b. “Rabota taynoy politsii [The Work of the Secret Police]” [in Russian]. In vol. 1 of Okhranka. Vospominaniya rukovoditeley politicheskogo syska [Okhrana. Memoirs of the Domestic Intelligence Head Officers]. 2 vols. Moskva [Moscow]: Novoye literaturnoye obozreniye.

Размещено на Allbest.ru